polity
Civil Disobedience 豆瓣
作者: William E. Scheuerman Polity 2018 - 2
What is civil disobedience? Although Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King helped to bring the idea to prominence, even today it remains unclear how we should best understand civil disobedience. Why have so many different activists and intellectuals embraced it, and to what ends? Is civil disobedience still politically relevant in today's hyper-connected world? Does it make sense, for example, to describe Edward Snowden's actions, or those of recent global movements like Occupy, as falling under this rubric? If so, how must it adapt to respond to the challenges of digitalization and globalization and the rise of populist authoritarianism in the West?
In this elegantly written introductory text, William E. Scheuerman systematically analyzes the most important interpretations of civil disobedience. Drawing out the striking differences separating religious, liberal, radical democratic, and anarchist views, he nonetheless shows that core commonalities remain. Against those who water down the idea of civil disobedience or view it as obsolescent, Scheuerman successfully salvages its central elements. The concept of civil disobedience, he argues, remains a pivotal tool for anyone hoping to bring about political and social change.
2020年8月30日 已读
讲了三种模式的公民不服从:religious, liberal, and democratic,也考察了Anarchism ,digitalization, postnationalization, privatization带来的变化。讨论网络中的不服从现象和阿伦特部分对照读很有意思。书本的写作背景是BLM,这个时候看本书,似乎没有任何时间上的间隔感。愈发觉得大百科全书的《认真对待权利》把civil disobedience翻译为善良违法是很严重的概念混淆。
polity 公民不服从 政治哲学