historiography
That Noble Dream 豆瓣
作者: Peter Novick Cambridge University Press 1988 - 9
The aspiration to relate the past 'as it really happened' has been the central goal of American professional historians since the late nineteenth century. In this remarkable history of the profession, Peter Novick shows how the idea and ideal of objectivity were elaborated, challenged, modified, and defended over the last century. Drawing on the unpublished correspondence as well as the published writings of hundreds of American historians from J. Franklin Jameson and Charles Beard to Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., and Eugene Genovese, That Noble Dream is a richly textured account of what American historians have thought they were doing, or ought to be doing, when they wrote history - how their principles influenced their practice and practical exigencies influenced their principles.
2013年12月31日 已读
我断断续续地读了两个月,终于读完了。这本书真的是必读书。1)作者于开篇第一章说要将果冻钉在墙上。这个果冻就是客观性。我的看法是果冻最后还是掉了下来。整本书里,对客观性最“翔实”的描述或许是兰克的名言“wie es eigentlich gewesen”。2)围绕客观性和历史学科的专门化,作者疏理了美国史学界的百年进程。3)作者将客观性和专门化两个问题时置于内外两部分中叙述。内部即史学家们各自的观点和争论。外部是整个美国大环境的变迁,如文化、经济和政治。4)我读完这本书后,可谓茅塞顿开。如我高中时期读津恩(Howard Zinn)的《美国人民的历史》时,我不理解津恩为何要从这个角度叙述美国历史。作者则于第十三章讲明原因。
historiography s 历史
那高尚的梦想 豆瓣
That Noble Dream
8.7 (6 个评分) 作者: [美] 彼得•诺维克 译者: 杨豫 生活·读书·新知三联书店 2009 - 2
《那高尚的梦想》是一部“观念史”的著作,探讨了自19世纪后期美国历史学诞生至20世纪末这一百多年中,“客观性”这一神圣理想和核心规范所遭遇的命运,即其形成和衍变,受到的挑战和修正,如何得到捍卫,以及20世纪60年代之后随着后现代观念的风起云涌,终于不可遏止地走向混乱和解体。
2013年12月31日 已读
读英文版;中文版的翻译尚可。这本书应是历史学(者)入门的必读书。用诉诸权威法(argumentum ad verecundiam),普林斯顿大学历史硕(博)士第一门课(HIS 500)就长期将这本书用作入门书本。
historiography s 历史
Metahistory 豆瓣
作者: Hayden White Johns Hopkins University Press 1975 - 8
In White's view, beyond the surface level of the historical text, there is a deep structural, or latent, content that is generally poetic and specifically linguistic in nature. This deeper content - the metahistorical element - indicates what an "appropriate" historical explanation should be.
Historiography in the Twentieth Century 豆瓣
作者: Georg G. Iggers Wesleyan 2005 - 2
Product Description
In this book, now published in 10 languages, a preeminent intellectual historian examines the profound changes in ideas about the nature of history and historiography. Georg G. Iggers fraces the basic assumptions upon which historical research and writing have been based, and describes how the newly emerging social sciences transformed historiography following World War II. The discipline's greatest challenge may have come in the last two decades, when postmodern ideas forced a reevaluation of the relationship of historians to their subject and questioned the very possibility of objective history. Iggers sees the contemporary discipline as a hybrid, moving away from a classical, macrohistorical approach toward microhistory, cultural history, and the history of everyday life. The new epilogue, by the author, examines the movement away from postmodernism towards new social science approaches that give greater attention to cultural factors and to the problems of globalization.